Which of these games do you think is better?

*cough*RedDeadRemdemption*cough* =P

I'm going to have to go with Red Dead, both were great games though.

My bro bought red dead the other day, I'll probably pick up my copy this weekend or next.

I have yet to play either...

I haven't played Alan Wake, but I'm going to vote RDR just because I'm sure it's a whole lot longer then Alan Wake.

I haven't played either .. I will eventually maybe..

allan wake is so much better red dead is just a ok game but everybody hopped on the bandwagon for it

'bout like comparing street fighter with c.o.d. but i think rdr

'bout like comparing street fighter with c.o.d. but i think rdr

I see what you are saying, and I agree.

I haven't played either games yet, but I think they will both have their pros and cons. If you like Single Player games, Alan Wake will provide a better experience. For multiplayer and messing around with friends, Red Dead will tickle your fancy. Although, I did hear RDR's story was really good. I still think Alan Wake's story would be superior.

If you already love sandbox games, there's no bandwagon to jump on. Its Free Roam mode is a great social game. Alan Wake is a single player game only. Two totally different games.

Alan Wake's story better be good. He's a writer and his story is coming to life. How terrible would it be, if the story was no good? lol

They are totally different experiences and should stand alone on their own merit. RDR is longer tho. I voted for Alan Wake because It deserves a better showing...lol...Doesn't mean I think it's "better".

My choice was not there so I added it.

As much as I love RDR, I will be playing 3DDGH for a long long time.

My choice was not there so I added it.

As much as I love RDR, I will be playing 3DDGH for a long long time.

I may try that.